Two ways to figure the break-even
The Federal Reserve Board's consumer guide to refinancing figures it the simple way: take your current monthly payment, subtract the new one to get your monthly savings, and divide the total refinancing costs by those savings. The answer is the number of months it takes to recover the costs. (The guide's worksheet uses the savings after taxes; this calculator uses them before taxes.)
That works when the new loan runs about as long as what is left on the old one. When it doesn't, the monthly payment can drop just because you are spreading the balance over more years. So this calculator also counts what you would still owe: it adds up the interest each loan charges, month by month, and finds the month when the interest you save covers the closing costs. From then on you are ahead whether you sell, refinance again or keep paying, and it works the same whether you pay the costs at closing or add them to the loan.
Example: $300,000 at 7.5% with 28 years left
Refinancing to 6.25% for 30 years with $6,000 in closing costs paid at closing lowers the principal and interest payment from $2,138.60 to $1,847.15, a saving of $291.45 a month. $6,000 divided by $291.45 is 21 months, and counting interest and what you still owe, you are ahead after 1 year 8 months. The same rate with other terms:
| New term | Payment | Ahead after | Saved over the loan |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30 years | $1,847.15 | 1 yr 8 mo | $47,597 |
| 20 years | $2,192.78 | 1 yr 7 mo | $186,304 |
| 15 years | $2,572.27 | 1 yr 6 mo | $249,565 |
| 10 years | $3,368.40 | 1 yr 5 mo | $308,364 |
"Saved over the loan" is the interest left on the current loan minus the new loan's interest and the closing costs.
When a lower payment costs more
Take $300,000 at 7% with 25 years left, refinanced to 6.5% for 30 years with $5,000 in closing costs. The payment drops from $2,120.34 to $1,896.20, and the simple break-even is 23 months. But the new loan adds five years of payments: counting interest, you are ahead only from 3 years 11 months to 15 years 2 months, and over the whole loan you pay $51,536.55 more. The Federal Reserve's guide makes the same point: a longer term increases the total you end up paying toward interest. If you plan to keep the loan to the end, compare the total interest under both loans, not just the payment.
Reading your Loan Estimate
- Closing costs. "Closing Cost Details" lists Loan Costs (A, origination charges, with any points shown as "% of Loan Amount (Points)"; B and C, services) and Other Costs (E, taxes and government fees; F, prepaids; G, escrow; H, other). Prepaids and escrow mostly pay for interest, insurance and taxes you would pay anyway, so they are left out here.
- In 5 Years. Page 3, "Comparisons," shows the total you will have paid in principal, interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs over 60 months, and the principal you will have paid off. The CFPB suggests subtracting the second from the first to get a five-year cost of borrowing, and notes that on average borrowers keep a mortgage for about five years. The table above does the same for both loans.
- No closing costs. The CFPB notes that loans advertised with no closing costs come with a higher monthly payment. Put the higher rate in and the costs at $0 to compare.
Before you refinance
- A prepayment penalty on your current loan is part of the cost of refinancing and makes the break-even longer, so add it to the closing costs. Your loan papers say whether you have one; on a Closing Disclosure it is the line labeled "Prepayment Penalty." For most home loans, federal rules allow one only on a qualified mortgage whose rate can't go up and that is not higher-priced, only in the first three years, and at most 2% of the balance prepaid in the first two years and 1% in the third.
- Points lower the rate for an upfront fee. Try the rate with and without them; the break-even shows whether you keep the loan long enough for them to pay.
- Ask about waiving costs. The Federal Reserve's guide suggests asking your current lender whether it would waive the prepayment penalty if you refinance with it.
What this calculator assumes
Both loans have a fixed rate, and payments cover principal and interest only. Taxes, insurance and PMI are left out, and so are tax effects. Your current payment is figured from the balance, rate and time left, so it should match your statement's principal and interest. Interest is figured each month on the balance and rounded to the cent, and the last payment covers the few cents of rounding. Cash-out refinances and adjustable rates are not covered.